Have you seen the headlines about the new School Food Standards for England? The government have published their response to the consultation and there is lots of information in the response and in the annex. They have also published some one page posters with the ‘permitted foods’ – for primary and separately for secondary. BUT at the time of writing this there are still questions as we don’t have the full guidance. Schools should not read what we currently have and base all their changes on that because there are gaps. That doesn’t mean you can’t get started with action though.
Here are some of the things we don’t yet know – some of these are very specific but still important for schools to know – and those checking compliance to know:
Food-based questions
- Will baked beans be limited? We know that baked beans can’t be counted as a vegetable on any day, or a pulse on pulse day but there are hints that baked beans will be limited in the frequency they are permitted. Current standards limit frequency.
- Do all desserts need to be below 10g sugar per 100g? The list in the glossary reads: “Desserts, such as ice cream, mousse/whips, cheesecake, frozen yoghurt, trifle, jelly, meringues, waffles, pancakes. Excludes yoghurt, custard, rice pudding. These must be less than 10g/100g total sugar and contain no sweeteners.” This could be interpreted as just the yoghurt, custard and rice pudding need to be less than 10g/100g total sugar – or it could be for the whole list. If schools can add as much sugar as they want (providing the dessert has a portion of fruit or vegetable in it) does that fit with the spirit of the Standards?
- Are starchy carbohydrates other than cereal, bread, no added sugar muesli, plain unsweetened porridge, teacakes, crumpets and unsweetened pancakes permitted at breakfast? We know that fried breads, pastries and croissants are not permitted but what about products made with potato or another flour which is not fried? What about cultural foods like dosa? The current standards talk about other starchy carbohydrates but we don’t have any reference to them in the information published so far.
- Would a sausage roll be permitted once a week on the menu? The Standards state “No more than 2 foods from this list may be served each week and foods from any 1 of these groups may be served once each week: 1) Batter-coated or breadcrumb-coated foods, 2) Foods containing pastry, 3) Processed meat, meat/poultry products.” Sausage rolls would fit into both category 2 and category 3 so would that be classed as 1 food or 2 foods? If it was only one, then a batter-coated or breadcrumb-coated food could also be provided. If it was 2 because it fit in both categories, then no other foods from this list could be included.
- Is tea, coffee and hot chocolate only permitted from September 2027-28 if it contains less than 5% added sugars or honey? The annex says there is no change in September 2027 to secondary school drinks however in the list of permitted drinks on the poster there is sugar limit for these drinks which is not in the current Standards.
Compliance questions
- What are the expectations of a lead governor . We know a lead governor must be appointed but we don’t know what their exact role is yet, what training they need, what training will be provided and whether they need specific qualifications.
- What the National Compliance Framework will look like
- What the National Monitoring System will require of schools and who will be involved in this
- How Ofsted will be involved. Currently we know that the DfE will work with Ofsted so relevant compliance monitoring information is passed to inspectors. What we don’t know is what Ofsted will do with that information.
So what can schools and caterers do next. There is a lot we already know so getting to grips with that and planning out how to start making menu changes is a good start. Food education – for example tasting, sensory play, cooking is also important to support children in this. And of course considering the children who might need more support with this transition. This includes children with SEND, sensory issues, medical diets and cultural needs. As well as this, keeping an eye out for the updated guidance which is due out soon.
If you need more support getting your school ready, do reach out. I worked on the pilot for the updated School Food Standards, have developed training for schools through The National College, and developed both menus and recipes for a variety of settings.
